RateIndex

FIFO versus metro pay: what a fair comparison looks like

16 November 2026 · RateIndex

FIFO versus metro pay: what a fair comparison looks like

FIFO versus metro pay: what a fair comparison looks like

A FIFO rate and a metro rate can both be correct and still be unsuitable for direct comparison. Before a steering committee reads them side by side, the question is whether they describe the same work. A defensible comparison makes that match visible.

Define the roster

Start by setting out what each rate covers: the hours, the rotation, the location and the period of work. A FIFO roster with long shifts and fixed rotations is not the same job as a metro role with standard hours, even when the job title is identical.

Separate the cost components

FIFO pay often sits alongside accommodation, travel and other allowances. Show these apart from base pay rather than folding them into one number. That way a reviewer can see what each figure includes and compare the parts that really match.

Match the sample

Compare FIFO and metro figures only where the sample sizes are comparable. If one side rests on a thin set of observations, say so. A gap in the data is more useful to a decision maker than a confident average that hides it.

Record each adjustment

Any conversion, loading or allowance you apply should be written down next to the figure it affects. When someone asks why the gap narrowed or widened, the answer should already be on the page.

Present the range

Show the comparison as a range, with the source for each input and the limits of the comparison. State plainly what it does not cover, such as seasonal rosters or roles outside the sample.

A short checklist

RateIndex keeps this audit trail with each benchmark, so the reasoning travels with the number. You can explore the RateIndex workspace to see how it works.

Benchmark rates with evidence, not vibes. RateIndex turns enterprise agreements, awards and salary guides into defensible rate benchmarks with a 90-day audit trail. Claim your workspace →